Why is Special Relativity Wrong (2)
Galileo might be wrong, Einstein could also be incorrect.
Listed below are all the possibilities:
|
Galileo's formula |
Einstein's formula |
Case 1 |
Wrong |
Wrong |
Case 2 |
Correct |
Wrong |
Case 3 |
Wrong |
Correct |
Case 4 |
Correct |
Correct |
Case 4 is not possible, because the two formulas contradict each other.
Case 1 & 2 can be omitted, as we are trying to prove that Special Relativity is wrong. If we assume Special Relativity is wrong, then no further discussion is needed.
So case 3 is the only possibility.
Does that mean Special Relativity is correct?
No, because in the first equation* of Special Relativity, the Galileo Transformation is used, or else the terms c-v and c+v would not appear:
Since it is built from the wrong basis, Special Relativity cannot be correct!
*It appears as the first equation in section 3, part I, of "On the Electrodynamics of Moving Bodies", the paper on Special Relativity by Einstein.